Because Trying to Seat 12 People at a Tiny Café Is a Nightmare
We’ve all been there—you try to book a dinner for a large group, and the restaurant acts like you just asked them to cater your wedding with zero notice. Sarasota has plenty of fantastic restaurants, but not all of them are built for big parties. If you’re looking for places that can actually handle your crew without making you wait three hours or split into five different tables, this list has you covered.
From birthday celebrations to company outings to family reunions, these Sarasota restaurants offer plenty of space, great food, and the kind of atmosphere that makes any occasion special.
🍽️ Best Upscale Restaurants for Large Groups
1. Michael’s On East
- Why It’s Great for Groups: If you’re looking for white-tablecloth elegance with a side of award-winning cuisine, this is the place. Their private dining rooms and group-friendly seating make it a top choice for celebrations.
- Must-Try Dish: Prime filet mignon—because if you’re going all out, you might as well go all out.
2. Marina Jack
- Why It’s Great for Groups: Waterfront dining, stunning sunset views, and multiple dining options (casual patio, fine dining, or a dinner cruise). If you want to impress out-of-town guests, this is your move.
- Must-Try Dish: Stuffed shrimp with crab meat—because seafood by the water just hits different.
3. Columbia Restaurant
- Why It’s Great for Groups: A Sarasota classic with a spacious dining room and a menu packed with Spanish and Cuban favorites. Bonus points for its historic St. Armands Circle location.
- Must-Try Dish: The 1905 Salad—the most famous salad in Florida (seriously, just trust me).
🍻 Best Casual & Fun Group Dining Spots
4. Gecko’s Grill & Pub
- Why It’s Great for Groups: A laid-back atmosphere with plenty of space, making it a great choice for sports teams, work outings, or just a casual night out.
- Must-Try Dish: The Gecko’s wings—perfect for sharing and pair well with their extensive beer selection.
5. Dry Dock Waterfront Grill
- Why It’s Great for Groups: Another waterfront gem with plenty of outdoor seating, making it perfect for group brunches or seafood feasts.
- Must-Try Dish: The grouper sandwich—one of the best in Sarasota.
6. Duval’s Fresh. Local. Seafood.
- Why It’s Great for Groups: They love hosting large parties and even offer a free shuttle service to and from the restaurant for groups. You read that right—free designated driver.
- Must-Try Dish: The seafood cioppino—a seafood lover’s dream in a bowl.
🍕 Best Sarasota Spots for Family Gatherings
7. Napulé
- Why It’s Great for Groups: Authentic Italian fare, a lively atmosphere, and enough space to handle even the loudest family dinner. Plus, wood-fired pizza makes everyone happy.
- Must-Try Dish: The truffle pizza—because cheese and truffles were meant to be together.
8. Owen’s Fish Camp
- Why It’s Great for Groups: Old Florida charm, legendary seafood, and a backyard patio with live music. If your group wants casual but still fantastic food, this is the spot.
- Must-Try Dish: The Low Country Boil—seafood, sausage, and corn in a giant pot of deliciousness.
9. Yoder’s Amish Restaurant
- Why It’s Great for Groups: Comfort food at its finest and big portions that won’t break the bank. Just be ready for a wait during peak hours.
- Must-Try Dish: The fried chicken—possibly the best in Sarasota.
🥂 Best Restaurants for Special Occasions
10. Shore
- Why It’s Great for Groups: Trendy, stylish, and right in the heart of St. Armands Circle. Perfect for a girls’ night out or a chic birthday celebration.
- Must-Try Dish: The lobster roll—because nothing says “special occasion” like buttery lobster on a toasted bun.
11. Bijou Garden Café
- Why It’s Great for Groups: A quaint, elegant spot that feels both intimate and celebratory. Ideal for anniversaries, bridal showers, or milestone birthdays.
- Must-Try Dish: The duck confit—because it’s rich, flavorful, and perfectly crispy.
🎉 Final Thoughts
If you’re planning a big night out, a special celebration, or just need a spot that won’t panic when you say “table for 12,” these Sarasota restaurants have you covered.
Did we miss your favorite group-friendly restaurant? Let me know by heading over to the contact page and sending it my way.
🚀 Next up: Sarasota’s best waterfront dining spots—because dinner always tastes better with an ocean view.